The Court of Appeal is the final court of appeal in New South Wales. The Court of Appeal hears applications for leave to appeal and appeals from single judges of the Supreme Court and from other NSW courts and tribunals. It has both appellate and supervisory jurisdiction in respect of all other courts in the State system. Usually a Full Court of three or more Judges sitting together will hear an appeal. However, appeals from a judgment of a Judge of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia or from a Court of summary jurisdiction will be heard by a single judge unless a judge considers that it is appropriate for the appeal to be heard by a Full Court. Decisions reserved; NSWCA decisions before the High Court; Speeches; Practice & procedure. Practice Note No. SC CA 1; Legislation, Regulations and Rules; Sources of New South Wales Court of Appeal Jurisdiction; Resources: Common Procedural and Preliminary Issues; Contact.
Help Community portal Recent changes Upload file. Download as PDF Printable version. Add links. Vice-regal appointment upon Premier's nomination, following advice of the Attorney General and Cabinet. High Court of Australia. Justice Tom Bathurst AC. Tom Bathurst AC.
Close to ten minutes later though, NSW Greens MLC David Shoebridge announced that he'd just been given the word that an appeal of the court ruling had been successful, so the 50, strong rally was now legal. And the waves of jubilation that swept the crowd were almost palpable. The Sydney barristers that argued the demonstration over the line were Stephen Lawrence and Felicity Graham. The pair had done so remotely from Dubbo , effectively saving all those present from being arrested or fined, which in this post-COVID lockdown grey area can be quite steep.
It outlined his intention to hold a public assembly of around 50 people to mark the deaths in custody of David Dungay Junior and George Floyd. Though, it became obvious the following week that the action was going to be much larger, as according to the Facebook event page, around 5, people would be attending and the scheduled meeting place next to Central would have to be changed to somewhere like Sydney Town Hall.
So, on 4 June, Bassi met with NSW police chief inspector Paul Dunstan to inform him that the rally would now comprise of many more participants and organisers wanted to march from Town Hall to Belmore Park. NSW police sergeant Hallett subsequently amended the original notice and then emailed it to Bassi.
But, on the day prior to the rally, the police commissioner moved to have the event banned in the Supreme Court. The laws that allow for the authorisation of a public assembly are contained in part 4 of the Summary Offences Act NSW. Section 23 outlines that a rally organiser must present an official notice to the commissioner outlining details at least seven days prior to its scheduled date.
Amendments of the details of a sanctioned assembly are then able to be made, under section 24 of the Act if the commissioner agrees to those changes. And section 26 sets out that if a notice is served less than seven days before an assembly, a court must then provide authorisation. On 5 June, Justice Fagan found that Fuller hadn't agreed to the amended notice and the changes to the event created a new one, which hadn't been lodged seven days earlier.
His Honour then refused an oral application for authorisation from Bassi on the basis of public health considerations. Protesters vowed to go ahead regardless. But, determined to overturn the ban, barristers working on behalf of Bassi lodged an urgent appeal with the Supreme Court just before noon on 6 June, about three hours before Sydney rallied for an end to police brutality towards First Nations people.
The appeal was argued on four grounds: that the justice had been in error in finding that the form hadn't been lodged within the set time, that the changes had led to a new notice, that the commissioner hadn't approved the amended notice, and that court authorisation was needed.
The barristers argued these points before Justices Tom Bathurst, Andrew Bell and Mark Leeming, who all agreed that the first three grounds of appeal had been made out, and due to this, there was no need to consider whether the fourth ground held any weight. The panel of justices ruled that Bassi had given a notice of intention to hold a public assembly more than seven days prior to it taking place, and while the changes made were very significant, they didn't lead to the original notice ceasing to legally apply and nor did the changes create a new one.
Their Honours noted that under section 24, the "particulars" of a public assembly may be altered with the agreement of the commissioner, and what occurred on 4 June with the changes was an alteration of the particulars, as opposed to the creation of a new form requiring court authorisation.
The notice contained in the email therefore constituted the original one with the implied authorisation from the police commissioner. And an attempt by the commissioner's lawyer to argue for a cross-appeal to the decision to allow the rally to go ahead during the course of the proceedings was dismissed in part due to the fact that it was raised only 20 minutes before the event was set to take place.
NSW police minister David Elliott said on Monday that he expects protests over 10 people to be deemed illegal.
This time the protest set to take place on Saturday afternoon at Sydney Town Hall is over the ongoing incarceration of refugees. Justice Michael Walton ruled the demonstration should not go ahead due to the continued threat of the coronavirus. However, protest organisers have vowed that it will take place. The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter.
Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances. All Rights Reserved. Password Passwords are Case Sensitive. Chief Justice . Andrew Bell. President, Court of Appeal . Julie Ward. John Basten.
Judge of Appeal . Robert Macfarlan. Anthony Meagher. Fabian Gleeson. Mark Leeming. Anthony Payne. Richard White. Lucy McCallum. Reginald Barrett. Arthur Emmett. Carolyn Simpson.